Saint or Goddess?


Later this week, February 1st will mark St Brigid’s Day. For those readers unfamiliar with her, Brigid is one of Ireland’s three national saints (the other two being Patrick and Columba), but not much is known about the woman. Supposedly she was born c.451, the daughter of a chieftain and a slave who had been baptised by St Patrick, was raised in a Druid household but then converted to Christianity and founded a religious house for women in what is now Kildare. Inevitably she also established other churches elsewhere in the country (early Irish saints were much given to roaming about the island) and performed many miracles. She is said to have died in 525 and a cult soon developed around her: the first account of Brigid’s life was produced during the following century by St Ultan of Ardbraccan. But did she actually exist? An increasingly popular theory proposes that Brigid was originally a pagan goddess, daughter of the Dagda (a kind of father-figure in ancient Irish mythology), and that with the arrival of Christianity her cult was simply transferred to a holy nun. The day on which she is annually celebrated, February 1st, happens to have been the occasion of a pagan festival marking the onset of Spring. This alternative image of Brigid is now widely promulgated: Dublin, for example, is about to host a five-day festival celebrating ‘the spirit and legacy of the Celtic goddess Brigit’, although quite what an imaginary deity’s spirit and legacy may be remains unclear. Meanwhile, in Kildare where the saint is supposed to have founded her community, the local authority is running Brigid 1500, a week-long festival intended to ‘celebrate and commemorate the extraordinary St Brigid, – A Woman, A Life, A Legacy- and the enduring impact of her life as we reach the 1500th anniversary of her passing.’





In the centre of Kildare town, St Brigid’s Cathedral is said to stand on the site where the aforementioned saint established a church and community of like-minded women in the year 480. This foundation survived long after Brigid’s death, becoming a double community of women and men, over which an Abbess ruled (as indeed, she held jurisdiction over the local bishop). Successive generations of nuns kept alive the memory of their founder by tending a fire which was never allowed to go out. In his Topographia Hibernia of c.1188, Gerald of Wales (otherwise known as Giraldus Cambrensis) wrote, ‘At Kildare, in Leinster, celebrated for the glorious Brigit, many miracles have been wrought worthy of memory. Among these, the first that occurs is the fire of St. Brigit, which is reported never to go out. Not that it cannot be extinguished, but the nuns and holy women tend and feed it, adding fuel, with such watchful and diligent care, that from the time of the Virgin, it has continued burning through a long course of years ; and although such heaps of wood have been consumed during this long period, there has been no accumulation of ashes.’ Gerald also noted that the fire was surrounded by a circular hedge made of stakes and brushwood, into which no man could enter. If any male was so foolish as to do so, ‘he will not escape the divine vengeance.’ Despite these supposedly secure defences, in 1220 Henry de Loundres, Archbishop of Dublin ordered the extinction of the fire. Meanwhile, the church first established by Brigid underwent similar traumas: it was pillaged and burnt by the Vikings in 835, then rebuilt before being burnt again on a couple of occasions in the mid-11th century and then plundered in 1136.





As seen today, St Brigid’s Cathedral was begun at some date in the 1220s by Ralph of Bristol, Bishop of Kildare. Like its predecessors, this suffered assault several times and, following the Dissolution of the Monasteries in the mid-16th century, fell into serious disrepair. The roof was taken off in 1588 and the building was judged ruinous in 1615. The diocese of Kildare was always among the poorest in the country, and this helps to explain why the cathedral was so often left in poor condition. In 1681 William Moreton embarked on restoring the building with what resources were available; he would write to the Duke of Ormond that he had ‘endeavoured the most since he came to Kildare to repair the insupportable ruins of it.’ Repairs to the choir, nave and chancel cost £500, of which £200 came from private subscriptions, with Moreton providing £112. Work was completed in 1686. Nevertheless, further dilapidation occurred and finally, in the mid-1870s and over the next 20 years, St Brigid’s Cathedral underwent a thorough restoration overseen by George Edmund Street, with an initial budget of £5,000 although the eventual cost was more than double this figure. This is the building seen today, rather severe with exposed stone walls and just a few ancient monuments, or parts of these, which had survived the various attacks on the fabric. Outside is a round tower, the second tallest in Ireland, which has similarly undergone repairs and improvements over the centuries. Brigid: Christian saint or pagan goddess? Take your choice…

6 comments on “Saint or Goddess?

  1. Vincent Delany says:

    Saint Brigids Cathedral is a remarkable building which gives us the atmosphere of the Middle Ages thanks to the sensitive work by George Edmund Street architect.

  2. Patrick says:

    What A wonderful Celtic dragon carved on that piece of stone in the window.

  3. Symmachus says:

    George Edmund Street was a harsh, insensitive restorer (see the fabric, notably the choir of Christ Church / Holy Trinity, Dublin), but the result would be impressive. It’s probably that the mediaeval cathedral was likely a mix of white wash and vivid colour. The name of Bridget is not much evidence, for there were Roman saints called Apollo or Mercury and so on. The fire is a possible even clear hint of pre Christian rites, but I’m not sure the evidence effaces the traditional idea of an aristocratic woman founding a monastery. Still Bridget could’ve been like that bishop of Ilium encountered by Julian the Apostate who also tended a local pagan temple as its priest, or perhaps a pagan priestess who became an abbess. Anyhow, I’ll have to visit this. The Irish Aesthete provides so many places!

    • Vincent Delany says:

      As I understand it, when Street was restoring St.Brigids cathedral in Kildare, the roof was gone, the walls partly demolished, and the original fabric in smithereens.
      I disagree with you wholehartedly in your suggestion that he was an insensitive restorer in Kildare. I believe he did not remove any intact fabric and that he built up what he found on site and put on a beautiful roof – possibly similar to the original roof.

      • Symmachus says:

        My brackets made it clear I was referring to Street’s restoration of Christ Church Cathedral which saw the loss of the 14th century long choir of Ap de St Paul was lost with Victoriana and medieval fabric carelessly mixed throughout the rest. Here, the cathedral seems utterly sparse, but given Streets own vividly colourly Anglo-Catholic creations, that was likely the choice of his patron.

  4. Its a beautiful church.
    Tom

Leave a Reply